I'm stuck between a 3.5 and a 4 so I'll give it a 4. I can see why people rave about this book, but I was still let down just a little. i am fairly new to adult romance so don't quite know I enjoy and while i did like this i'm not sure it is the perfect romance for me. I enjoyed the interactions between Tiffy and Leon, especially the post-it notes throughout. I didn't enjoy the narrative style of Leon's POV and I understand the choice was made for it to read similar to the notes he might make at his job, but it wasn't for me. I also didn't enjoy how quickly Leon gave up on Tiffy when he thought he lost her. I know we spend the whole novel learning that Leon doesn't open up to people, but he did open up to Tiffy so it seems out of character for him to not even ask her, especially with everything he knows about Justin. However, I do think there were a lot of very sweet moments between Tiffy and Leon, especially at the beach, and liked the pacing of the romance.